AI in Claims Management - It's Not About Losing the Human Touch

Imagine strolling into your favorite neighborhood diner, where the waitress knows your name and asks about your family as she pours your coffee. Now, picture that same diner replaced with automated kiosks taking orders and robotic servers delivering meals. While the service might be efficient, you'd likely miss the friendly smile and personal connection that make the experience special.

In today's fast-paced, tech-driven world, insurance companies are rapidly adopting AI and automation to streamline claims processes and enhance efficiency. However, amidst this digital transformation, it's crucial to remember that the human connection is what clients remember the most in the claims process. Keeping the brand strong is most important—no carrier wants to mess with that. Yet, AI in claims processing, along with automation, are disruptive forces that insurers cannot ignore.

 Balancing the two is critical in ensuring that technological advancements enhance, rather than replace, the personal interactions that define exceptional customer service.

The Investment Paradox: High Spending, Low Satisfaction

Over the past few years, the insurance industry has invested more than $8 billion in digital transformation initiatives. These investments aimed to streamline processes and deliver sleek digital experiences. However, overall claims satisfaction has declined, reaching a seven-year low, as reported by J.D. Power. This decline suggests that while digital tools enhance efficiency, they may inadvertently neglect the personalized service that is crucial during times of financial and emotional stress.

Claims Management: The Predominant Cost Driver

Claims processing represents the most significant cost component for property and casualty insurers. In 2020, paid losses combined with investigative and settlement expenses accounted for approximately 70% of U.S. premiums collected, and this has not shown a decrease since then. This substantial expenditure underscores the pressure on insurers to enhance claims efficiency. 

The Financial Impact of Inaccurate Data

Even skilled professionals can be hampered by inaccurate data, leading to misinformed decisions and potential financial losses. A study by MIT Sloan Management Review estimates that poor data quality can cost companies 15% to 25% of their revenue. For an insurer with annual revenues of $10 billion, this translates to potential losses ranging from $1.5 billion to $2.5 billion annually. 

These losses arise from process inefficiencies, increased error rates, and missed opportunities due to flawed data. Inaccurate figures can lead to mispricing of policies; if an insurer underestimates risk due to faulty data, they may charge premiums that are too low, resulting in financial losses.

Moreover, the absence of standardized denial management processes contributes to inaccurate reporting, leading to data discrepancies and errors. In short, even highly skilled claims management teams are only as good as the data they have. Today, technology remains the backbone of all initiatives.

Customer Perception and Claims Handling

Our customers are doing their homework. Customer perception of an insurer's claims handling process significantly influences purchasing decisions. A Deloitte survey revealed that 44% of U.S. consumers research an insurer's claims experience before purchasing auto or homeowners coverage. This statistic emphasizes that a reputation for efficient and empathetic claims processing is a competitive differentiator. Insurers focusing solely on digital efficiency without maintaining the human element risk damaging their reputation and losing potential customers.

The Evolving Roles of Claims Professionals

As insurers roll out more digital tools, they're speeding up claims processing and automating decisions for many cases. This shift boosts productivity and frees up time for claims professionals. Does this mean automation will replace human roles? The answer largely depends on how well professionals adapt and continue to add value to the customer experience.

With new data and technology at their fingertips, the day-to-day tasks of claims professionals are evolving. Routine activities like data collection, verification, and loss estimation are increasingly handled by automated systems. This change allows professionals to focus more on complex cases and customer interactions, ensuring that while technology handles the repetitive tasks, the human touch remains central to the claims process.

Some worry that AI  in claims processing might replace jobs and reduce empathy in claims handling. However, automating repetitive tasks allows professionals to focus on cases that require human judgment and compassion. For instance, while minor claims like a damaged phone can be resolved quickly through automation, more serious incidents, such as a house fire, need personal attention to address all complexities and provide emotional support.

So how does the human empathy factor come in?

Automation is making waves in the insurance world,  and no one is going to roll back on this technology, especially in handling repetitive tasks like data collection and paperwork. But for these tech tools to make a difference, claims professionals need to get comfortable with them and be ready to tackle more complex issues once the routine stuff is off their plates.

So, what does this shift look like? Some folks might dive into advanced data analysis, overseeing risk portfolios instead of just individual claims. Others could zero in on spotting fraud, dissecting coverage details, or sorting out tricky claims. And rather than just stepping in after something goes wrong, claims teams could team up with underwriters, sharing insights on how policies are actually working in the real world.

But here's the catch: even with all this tech, the human touch is still crucial. As one Chief Claims Officer pointed out, "While automation can cut time and expenses, that doesn't necessarily mean you need to do away with customer interaction, which is an essential element to the overall experience, especially if a problem arises."

Take disaster response teams, for example. When catastrophe strikes, it's essential to have people on the ground offering support. The same CCO emphasized, "The last thing you should do is cut those people, as you still need field agents to reach out in empathy to traumatized customers. You can't do it all with drones and bots.”

Here are a few scenarios where human intervention has made a significant difference:

1. Personal Injury Claims: Aviva, a prominent insurance company, employs a "double helix" approach in their claims process. This method allows for seamless transitions between digital tools and human interaction, optimizing both business efficiency and customer experience. For instance, in cases involving personal injuries, Aviva defaults to human engagement, recognizing the necessity of empathy and personalized communication in such sensitive situations.

2. High Net Worth Clientele: Criterion, a subsidiary of Charles Taylor, specializes in managing complex claims for high-net-worth clients. According to Managing Director Helena Evans, while technical expertise is essential, the human touch—through clear communication, managing expectations, and responsiveness—is equally crucial. This personalized approach ensures that discerning clients feel valued and understood throughout the claims process.

3. Preventing Litigation: Patrick J. Sodoro, a managing partner at the law firm Sodoro, Mooney, and Lenaghan, emphasizes the importance of direct communication between claims adjusters and claimants. He says that a lack of human interaction can lead to insufficient documentation and an understanding of the claim's context, increasing the likelihood of disputes escalating to litigation. So, human involvement is key to capturing the full narrative and resolving issues amicably.

In short, while automation is a game-changer for efficiency, it doesn't replace the need for empathetic, personal interactions. By embracing new tech and stepping into more specialized roles, claims professionals can enhance customer service and keep that all-important human connection alive.

Talk with our team of experts today about the SimpleINSPIRE Core Insurance Platform.